Be thoughtful about the distinction between content what you are reporting and structure where it goes in the manuscript. I always comment on the form of the paper, highlighting whether it is well written, has correct grammar, and follows a correct structure.
I try hard to avoid rude or disparaging remarks. Is the sequence of methods clear and pertinent? J African Earth Sci. Third, I make sure that the design of the methods and analyses are appropriate. If there are any aspects of the manuscript that I am not familiar with, I try to read up on those topics or consult other colleagues.
Reviewing is a great learning experience and an exciting thing to do. Does it accurately summarize the article? Additional analyses 16 Describe methods of additional analyses such as sensitivity or subgroup analyses, meta-regressionif done, indicating which were pre-specified.
If jargon has to be utilized keep it to a minimum and explain the terms you do use clearly. Your labmates and collaborators are invaluable resources. After that, I transitioned to full-time reading and writing.
I am more willing to review for journals that I read or publish in. Rather than asking one or two people to help you edit the entire article, break it up into sections and ask a different colleague for his or her expert help in revising just one section on a topic with which you know he or she is familiar.
Third, I make sure that the design of the methods and analyses are appropriate. The fundamental rationale of writing a review article is to make a readable synthesis of the best literature sources on an important research inquiry or a topic.
Do not include speculative statements or additional material; however, based upon your findings a statement about potential changes in clinical practice or future research opportunities can be provided here.
Did the research reported in your article result in the formulation of new questions or hypotheses by the authors, by other researchers? In a systematic review with a focused question, the research methods must be clearly described. When diving in deeper, first I try to assess whether all the important papers are cited in the references, as that also often correlates with the quality of the manuscript itself.
I consider four factors: Look at research articles to see how other people have used this work; what range of journals have cited this article?
As I go along, I use a highlighter and other pens, so the manuscript is usually colorful after I read it. If your instructor has not provided a format for your critique, there are two possible ways you might present it. Depending on how much time I have, I sometimes also end with a section of minor comments.
Approach B Another common way to structure a journal article critique is the following: What kind of data can be obtained using each technique? To what extent does the Discussion place the findings in a wider context and achieve a balance between interpretation and useful speculation versus tedious waffling?
Publishing a scientific manuscript on manual therapy. There is a consensus that a review should be written in a systematic fashion, a notion that is usually followed. I do this because editors might have a harder time landing reviewers for these papers too, and because people who aren't deeply connected into our research community also deserve quality feedback.When I undertook the task of writing a scientific literature review article last year, I had hoped that a Google search would reveal a handful of how-to pages thoughtfully created by.
Writing a review article is a wonderful way to develop and exercise your scientist skill set. If you dread the thought of writing a review, or if you’re currently stuck trying to write one, hopefully this post will help you get things moving - remember you're becoming an expert in your field and are the perfect person to be writing the review!
Journal-specific instructions. When you sit down to write the review, make sure you familiarize yourself with any journal-specific guidelines (these will be noted in the journal’s guide for authors available on each journal’s homepage).
First read the article.
Sometimes, journal editors will invite scientists to write a review for their journal. Choosing a Topic If you need to write a review article but don't know where to start, keep some of these tips in mind. The Journal of Paleontological Sciences: dominicgaudious.net 1 How to Write a Scientific Article _____ Kenneth Carpenter– Curator of Lower Vertebrate Paleontology, Denver Museum of Nature & Science, Colorado Blvd., Denver, CO When I undertook the task of writing a scientific literature review article last year, I had hoped that a Google search would reveal a handful of how-to pages thoughtfully created by veterans of this particular writing process.Download